We’ve talked in the past about following three year averages and trusting in veterans. It’s important to stick with the guys who have been providing fantasy value for more than just one year. Studying the trends of each player can be time consuming but can go a long way to helping you stick with those players who will give you the best value throughout the draft. The good owners will stick with the veterans who give them the best value at each draft spot, rather than reaching too early for someone they hope gives them a chance at a breakout player. The best owners will know when to cut ties with a veteran who has been one of the most reliable major leaguers and fantasy players.
Last season, Roy Halladay suffered through one of his worst campaigns in recent history. He finished the season with an ERA over 4 for the first time since 2004. And it isn’t like it was a 4.02 ERA. When 2012 was over, he had an ERA of 4.50 and a WHIP of 1.22. Due to a strain behind his right shoulder, he only made 25 starts. Much like on the positive side, one season does not make a trend. Two spring trainings and one season, is the beginnings of a trend.
Last spring, Halladay struggled with his control and his velocity. It was explained away with the typical preseason justifications. Halladay could turn it on when he wanted and he was working through some new grips on pitches and so on. Then he turned in the 2012 that he did.
Now we have to take a long, hard look at Halladay’s latest spring training start and see if the end is near for the Doc. On Tuesday, the righty gave up seven runs on six hits in just 2 2/3 innings. His velocity was clocked between just 84 and 88 mph. Those numbers just won’t cut it when the season rolls around. We saw similar issues last spring. He also walked four batters and hit another.
Much like one season doesn’t make a trend, one start doesn’t either, but all of these are facts of the past year and a half. I had looked at Halladay as a major bounce back candidate when pitchers and catchers reported. He has a great history and the injury seemed like the perfect reason for his down season. At the age of 35 though, it would seem that his time as a fantasy ace, and most likely a MLB ace, are coming to an end.
Halladay can no longer be considered a value pick in the early rounds of a draft. Keep an eye on his velocity as the spring moves forward and if he drops to the late single digit rounds, consider taking him if you expect him to rebound into the season. If you see these trends as the beginning of the downward spiral, then be very wary of Halladay and don’t trust him to provide his usual WHIP and ERA this season.